I just wanted a space where I could write in a semi-academic fashion about topics that were bothersome or interesting. The scope of this writing will be within the topics of moral issues, science, skepticism or occasionally the sobering explanations of drunken tirades.
June 30, 2010
Mixed Martial Arts: The Staph Infection Conspiracy Theory
My article on pets and inheritance wasn't as well received as I'd hoped, but I with this post I'll get back to my bread and butter, skepticism. I'm going to have to bring in a topic that I haven't talked about much, but does take up quite a few nights of my life. I'm Steve and I'm an MMA junkie. The bustling blog audience, 'Hi Steve'. I haven't missed watching a UFC or Strikeforce event in quite a while and try to watch the big fights from both Dream and Bellator. So when I learned about the Matt Hamill vs Keith Jardine conspiracy I knew that it would be something I would blog about.
Now for those of you unlucky enough to have missed the fight it can be viewed from this link. It's pretty long, 23 minutes, so if your of a more genteel nature you can just look at the picture at the top. I am the first to admit that I am not a medical doctor, and spent most of the fight wondering what the heck that red spot Matt Hamill's back was. After reading the reports and listening to the post fight conference, I learned that it was a hardened red boil that resulted from having a staph infection. This is what Medicine.net had to say about staph infections, staph infection is a potentially very bad, but it can also be mild and require no treatment. It goes on to say that there are,
"Over 30 different types of Staphylococci can infect humans, but most infections are caused by Staphylococcus aureus. Staphylococci can be found normally in the nose and on the skin (and less commonly in other locations) of 25%-30% of healthy adults. In the majority of cases, the bacteria do not cause disease. However, damage to the skin or other injury may allow the bacteria to overcome the natural protective mechanisms of the body, leading to infection."
So that's a brief general overview of what staph infection is, and that boil was looked at by 3 doctors. Kevin Iole noted in his mailbag that those three doctors were, "Matt Hamill's personal doctor, Dr. Vicki Mazzorana of the NSAC and Dr. Jeff Davidson, who works for the UFC. All three cleared him to fight and said he posed no risk. The scab was hard and the doctors said that even if it had come off during the fight, there was no chance of it affecting Jardine."
Which is fairly consistent with Medicine.net saying that, "In cases of minor skin infections, Staphylococcal infections are commonly diagnosed by their appearance without the need for laboratory testing." So I don't get the impression that staph is terribly hard to diagnose, and three doctors confirmed that Matt had a non-infectious staff infection that posed no threat to anyone.
Yet there is a growing opinion on the internet from MMA Junkie, MMA Convert, and Fight Opinion that allowing Matt Hamil to fight was a poor Medical decision. Fight opinion starts right off by noting that after the fight Matt Hamil was going to start taking antibiotics for treatment of the staph and asking why does Matt need antibiotics if the staff is healed. Well the implication may not be as bad as it seems. Medicine.net says that, "Minor skin infections are usually treated with an antibiotic ointment such as a nonprescription triple-antibiotic mixture. In some cases, oral antibiotics may be given for skin infections. Additionally, if abscesses are present, they are surgically drained." So it could be just a minor infection that was going to get some nonprescription cream on it.
Then Fight Opinion spends a long time talking about Vicki Mazzorana, and how she had a clinic temporary closed for violations, a violation of no sterilizing a machine in particular. From this the Zack Arnold of fight opinion seems to imply that because she once was guilty of providing a realm for infection, that she would do so again. Although he could just be saying that she has been guilty of poor decisions and practice in the past, if so then fine, but Matt Hamil was also looked at by two other doctors that confirmed her opinion.
To argue that letting Matt Hamil fight was a poor medical decision is an understandable position, understandable, but I think wrong. It is hard to diagnose people from afar, and three doctors that were able to form a real diagnoses all agreed that the staph infection posed no threat to anyone. To say that Matt should have been sent to a dermatologist is reasonable, and it would have added some comfort to the decision, but it wasn't deemed necessary by everyone who had the most information about what was going on.
I'll take those 3 confirmed opinions over the speculation of people Dr. Johnny 'The Fight Doc' Benjamin. Yet, the semi-reasonable opinions of questioning the medical decision has lead to some people like Eddie Goldman on his radio show saying that, "Fighter safety is being thrown out the window by these crazy commissions who are working to please the promoters rather than protect the fighters." and people asking questions like this to Kevin Iole, "It was obvious that Matt “The Hammer” Hamill had a staph infection on Saturday when he fought Keith Jardine on 'The Ultimate Fighter Finale' in Las Vegas, yet he was still allowed to fight. Why did the Nevada Athletic Commission allow Matt to fight? Do you think the UFC had anything to do with it? Having Matt pull out of the fight would’ve been a huge blow. I really think this is unprofessional and dangerous to everyone who was in the cage or around it. This staph infection is really contagious. I don’t see why this issue isn’t getting a lot more attention. Everyone should be tested after the finale because of this screw-up."
Now these are the more untenable positions. That not only was there a poor medical decision being made, the poor medical decision was being made because the UFC wanted the co-main event of The Ultimate Fighter Final to go on. There is no evidence of this at all.
Not only is there no evidence, and it doesn't even make sense. If the staph was infectious the UFC would have came out looking horrible, because a UFC doctor also cleared Hamill. The UFC might have gotten 3 of its fighter infected with staph (2 now that Jardine has been cut), and one of those would have been The Ultimate Fighter Court Maggee, which is a pretty big loss. Also with the way blood was flying around in that fight, someone ringside could have been infected and that could have turned out to be a minor PR nightmare.On top of that all three doctors would be in risk of losing their medical licenses.
Also the UFC would have to count on no one it paid off coming out agianst them and stating what had happened. It just all adds up to having no value to anyone involved, the doctors or the UFC and there is no evidence for it. This conspiracy just lacks any plausibility.
Thanks for reading,
the moral skeptic
June 24, 2010
A Glimpse at Pet Inheritance
Well for my last posting I had to read a fair bit about pet inheritance and I didn't manage to cover all the subject matter I wanted to cover. This post will complete my thoughts about pet inheritance and I'll have some new subject matter to post about in the near future. I'm going to talk about two subjects in this post, the options for pet inheritance and my gut reaction to people leaving vast amounts of money to pets while leaving little to anyone else.
There is some pretty interesting and astounding information to be found when you scratch the surface of pet inheritance. The first interesting fact is how wide-pet inheritance actually is. It is not just the ultra rich making trusts for their pets. One article from yahoo states that, "Approximately 25 per cent of American pet owners have provided for their pets in either a will or trust, according to the American Bar Association estimate." Another interesting blog post talks about 7 dogs and cats that are 'Actually Richer than You.' due to the inheritance set up to provide for them. So there are both many rich and not to rich pets out there.
Which brings up the question, how does it work that an animal gets all that money? As I'm sure your aware that gluing a few 1000 bills to your dog/cat will not ensure that it is well taken care of after your passing, also the giving of money to an animal could be void depending on where you live.
John C. Martin comes up with three solutions. 1. Give your pet to a friend/relative. 2. Give your pet to an animal protection agency. 3. Make a Pet trust.
John comes up with some pretty good cons with number 1. stating that, "First, the friend or relative may not want to take care of your pet. Even if they express a desire today, your friend or relative may move away or face new life circumstances, making them unable or unwilling to provide proper care and support for your pet. Second, once your friend takes legal ownership of your pet, there is no guarantee that they will fulfill your desires, whether expressed orally or in a will. A worst-case scenario is an immediate euthanization of the pet upon a change of ownership, regardless of your best intentions."
He also has good cons agianst number 2, "A gift to an organization like the SPCA is an excellent solution for many pet owners. Yet, for many, such a gift may not be sufficiently personal. Moreover, it cannot be guaranteed exactly how money for long term financial support will be provided and whether proper placement of the pet can be achieved." So if you really believe in the organization and what it stands for this is a good option, but if you want your pet to live in luxury then it probably won't work for you.
3. is where it really gets interesting. It is where you set up an account with an amount of money for the pet and can nominate both a caretaker and a trustee. With this option you can budget out how the money is to be spent and the caretaker is to follow that budget. The trustee is then responsible for checking up and make sure the money is spent in the proper way. Yet, John finds problems with this too, "The expenses associated with administering a pet trust may rule out their use unless they are funded with a relatively large amount of money. Finally, while enforcement mechanisms under a pet trust are better than the alternatives, there is still no guarantee that the trustee will act completely in the pet’s interest."
It is also interesting to note the difference it makes on the event of the pets death. When the pet with the trust dies there is a 'remainder beneficiary' which gets the remaining amount of money. Naming either the caretaker or trustee as the beneficiary gives them an incentive to kill the pet, especially if the pets budget and overall value are high. So a person should name a third party or a charity, in which case the 3rd party or charity has an interest in the death of the pet. Not only that the caretaker and trustee might feel slighted that they are being entrusted with the dogs care, but none of the money, so you might have to put them in your will in other ways.
All this boils down to a pet owner having to trust someone upon their death. In the trust set up they have to believe that two or possibly more people will fulfill their wishes. In 2. they have to trust a company and the pet might not live in great surroundings for a while. In 1. you just have to trust one person, but their is no recourse if this person was to change their mind about your agreement.
Now that's the basics of pet inheritance, yet one issue still bothers me a little. This issue would be if the ladies in my last post didn't leave any money to charity and instead left everything to their dogs, which is how the media largely protrayed it. I read some forums and a lot of people responded like I did before I did any research. They said that this lady was out of touch and horrible; it was a slap in societies face. The money could have done so much to numerous causes, yet ended up being used in almost the most selfish way imaginable.
This reaction was then responded to by a minority in a libertarian way saying something like 'She earned the money so she can leave it or spend it in any way she wants.' I have no problem with this and it is a valid rebuttal, but just as someone who would burn their money could be criticized, so can someone who gives it frivolously to individual animals. Everyone has the free speech to say that, the money was utterly wasted and could have been spent on much better things, and it erroneous that it was her money. It is obvious she could spend the money however she chooses, but that doesn't mean that choice is devoid of criticism.
I think a quote can be changed to fit that sort of spending. The original being Jean Rostand's quote, "Kill a man, and you are a murderer. Kill millions of men, and you are a conqueror. Kill everyone, and you are a god." Leave billions to one dog and you are deplorable. Leave billions to millions of animals and you are beneficent. Tell everyone to read my blog and you are God.
thanks for reading
-the moral skeptic
There is some pretty interesting and astounding information to be found when you scratch the surface of pet inheritance. The first interesting fact is how wide-pet inheritance actually is. It is not just the ultra rich making trusts for their pets. One article from yahoo states that, "Approximately 25 per cent of American pet owners have provided for their pets in either a will or trust, according to the American Bar Association estimate." Another interesting blog post talks about 7 dogs and cats that are 'Actually Richer than You.' due to the inheritance set up to provide for them. So there are both many rich and not to rich pets out there.
Which brings up the question, how does it work that an animal gets all that money? As I'm sure your aware that gluing a few 1000 bills to your dog/cat will not ensure that it is well taken care of after your passing, also the giving of money to an animal could be void depending on where you live.
John C. Martin comes up with three solutions. 1. Give your pet to a friend/relative. 2. Give your pet to an animal protection agency. 3. Make a Pet trust.
John comes up with some pretty good cons with number 1. stating that, "First, the friend or relative may not want to take care of your pet. Even if they express a desire today, your friend or relative may move away or face new life circumstances, making them unable or unwilling to provide proper care and support for your pet. Second, once your friend takes legal ownership of your pet, there is no guarantee that they will fulfill your desires, whether expressed orally or in a will. A worst-case scenario is an immediate euthanization of the pet upon a change of ownership, regardless of your best intentions."
He also has good cons agianst number 2, "A gift to an organization like the SPCA is an excellent solution for many pet owners. Yet, for many, such a gift may not be sufficiently personal. Moreover, it cannot be guaranteed exactly how money for long term financial support will be provided and whether proper placement of the pet can be achieved." So if you really believe in the organization and what it stands for this is a good option, but if you want your pet to live in luxury then it probably won't work for you.
3. is where it really gets interesting. It is where you set up an account with an amount of money for the pet and can nominate both a caretaker and a trustee. With this option you can budget out how the money is to be spent and the caretaker is to follow that budget. The trustee is then responsible for checking up and make sure the money is spent in the proper way. Yet, John finds problems with this too, "The expenses associated with administering a pet trust may rule out their use unless they are funded with a relatively large amount of money. Finally, while enforcement mechanisms under a pet trust are better than the alternatives, there is still no guarantee that the trustee will act completely in the pet’s interest."
It is also interesting to note the difference it makes on the event of the pets death. When the pet with the trust dies there is a 'remainder beneficiary' which gets the remaining amount of money. Naming either the caretaker or trustee as the beneficiary gives them an incentive to kill the pet, especially if the pets budget and overall value are high. So a person should name a third party or a charity, in which case the 3rd party or charity has an interest in the death of the pet. Not only that the caretaker and trustee might feel slighted that they are being entrusted with the dogs care, but none of the money, so you might have to put them in your will in other ways.
All this boils down to a pet owner having to trust someone upon their death. In the trust set up they have to believe that two or possibly more people will fulfill their wishes. In 2. they have to trust a company and the pet might not live in great surroundings for a while. In 1. you just have to trust one person, but their is no recourse if this person was to change their mind about your agreement.
Now that's the basics of pet inheritance, yet one issue still bothers me a little. This issue would be if the ladies in my last post didn't leave any money to charity and instead left everything to their dogs, which is how the media largely protrayed it. I read some forums and a lot of people responded like I did before I did any research. They said that this lady was out of touch and horrible; it was a slap in societies face. The money could have done so much to numerous causes, yet ended up being used in almost the most selfish way imaginable.
This reaction was then responded to by a minority in a libertarian way saying something like 'She earned the money so she can leave it or spend it in any way she wants.' I have no problem with this and it is a valid rebuttal, but just as someone who would burn their money could be criticized, so can someone who gives it frivolously to individual animals. Everyone has the free speech to say that, the money was utterly wasted and could have been spent on much better things, and it erroneous that it was her money. It is obvious she could spend the money however she chooses, but that doesn't mean that choice is devoid of criticism.
I think a quote can be changed to fit that sort of spending. The original being Jean Rostand's quote, "Kill a man, and you are a murderer. Kill millions of men, and you are a conqueror. Kill everyone, and you are a god." Leave billions to one dog and you are deplorable. Leave billions to millions of animals and you are beneficent. Tell everyone to read my blog and you are God.
thanks for reading
-the moral skeptic
Labels:
Freedom of Speech,
Inheritance,
Libertarian,
pet inheritance,
Trusts
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


